Satoshi-Era Wallet Served in Lawsuit Moves Its Bitcoin

Satoshi-Era Wallet Served in Lawsuit Moves Its Bitcoin

Satoshi-Era Wallet Served in Lawsuit Moves Its Bitcoin

A Satoshi-era wallet served in a lawsuit moved its bitcoin in November, challenging a claim that the coins had been abandoned. The transfer came months after lawyers sent a court-approved notice to the wallet, but it does not identify who controls the funds or why they moved.

The wallet had held 75 BTC since 2011. On Thursday evening, someone with access to its keys moved the holdings, worth roughly $5 million, to a new address, according to CoinDesk’s report. The move followed a legal notice sent earlier this year as part of a New York case seeking ownership of bitcoin held in thousands of inactive wallets.

The lawsuit was filed by a plaintiff identified as Noah Doe and two Wyoming companies. It asks a court to declare the plaintiffs owners of bitcoin held in 39,069 addresses. The complaint argues that wallets inactive for at least five years contain lost property that can be claimed under New York law.

Marble floor and stone columns inside the New York County Supreme Court rotunda
Marble floor and stone columns inside the New York County Supreme Court rotunda. Photo: history.nycourts.gov.

Satoshi-Era Wallet Served Under Court Notice

The complaint seeks roughly 3.8 million BTC, including coins attributed to Bitcoin creator Satoshi Nakamoto, CoinDesk previously reported. The court allowed the plaintiffs to notify unidentified wallet holders through tiny bitcoin payments carrying messages that linked to legal papers. The address that later moved its holdings was listed as defendant No. 3,419 in the amended complaint.

The notice did not establish who owned or controlled the wallet. Nor does the subsequent movement prove that its controller received or acted because of the lawsuit. It does show that the bitcoin was not beyond anyone’s ability to access, while leaving the identity of that person unresolved.

The transfer also complicates the lawsuit’s central contention that the coins had been abandoned. The case asks the court to treat long periods of inactivity as evidence of lost property, but a wallet’s renewed activity raises questions about that premise. The movement alone does not resolve the legal question or establish ownership.

Wallet Movement Leaves Ownership Unresolved

Other addresses named in the case have also moved. CoinDesk reported in June that another wallet named in the case had also moved some of its long-dormant holdings. The latest transfer remained at its new address as of Friday evening, the report said.

The lawsuit’s practical limits remain significant. Even if the plaintiffs win, a court ruling would not give them the private keys needed to spend bitcoin held in the wallets. The complaint says an expert hired by the plaintiffs valued the “found wallets” at less than $10 because recovering their contents was uncertain.

The dispute is part of a wider set of legal and security stories involving cryptocurrency. Related coverage has examined a crypto exchange facing an investor claim, a separate lawsuit over frozen tokens, and reported crypto thefts. Those cases concern different parties and events.

For now, the wallet movement provides no public answer about the holder’s identity, the reason for the transfer, or whether the lawsuit influenced it. The New York case remains the forum where the plaintiffs are asking a court to decide whether the long-inactive holdings can be claimed as abandoned property.

Facebook
Pinterest
LinkedIn
WhatsApp
Related Articles

Jordan French is the Executive Editor of Block Telegraph. He is a multi-media tech journalist on the editorial staff at TheStreet.com and a Fast 50 and Inc. 500-ranked entrepreneur. He is the founder of Notability Partners and the co-founder of BNB Shield, Lisbon Hill Farms, BeeHex, BlockTelegraph, and Grit Daily. A biomedical engineer and intellectual-property attorney, French is the author of upcoming book, The Gritty Entrepreneur.