Senate Democrats are pressing the Commodity Futures Trading Commission to withdraw its demand that prediction markets stop blocking customers in restricted jurisdictions. The lawmakers say the directive conflicts with court orders, as disputes over whether these contracts fall under federal derivatives law or state gambling rules continue. Their letter asks the agency to wait until the cases are resolved, CoinDesk reported.
The CFTC told regulated platforms to operate without state-by-state restrictions or explain within 30 days why they could not. The agency says designated contract markets must function nationally under the Commodity Exchange Act. The senators say companies instead face court orders requiring them to stop offering certain contracts in specific places.
Democrats Tell CFTC Its Directive Conflicts With Court Orders
“Your unilateral decision directly conflicts with active court orders, undermines state and tribal law, and must be reversed,” the lawmakers wrote. The letter came from Democrats on the Senate Agriculture Committee, which oversees the CFTC.

The senators pointed to orders affecting prediction contracts in Michigan, Nevada and Washington, as well as the lands of two California tribes. They said courts had required platforms to use geofencing in those areas. In their view, the CFTC’s directive could encourage companies to offer contracts barred by active orders.
Chairman Mike Selig has argued that federal oversight preempts state efforts to restrict platforms such as Kalshi and Polymarket. He said derivatives markets must operate on a uniform national basis. The agency and states have been litigating the issue, and the source said multiple federal appellate courts had sided with states.
Related coverage includes Blockchain.com’s CFTC registration bid and Democrats weighing a broader crypto bill.
State Cases Keep the Federal Dispute Active
Louisiana is the latest jurisdiction pursuing restrictions. After a judge cleared the way for state officials to prohibit prediction market contracts, the Louisiana Gaming Control Board said it considers purported sporting event contracts and certain other event contracts illegal gambling. A temporary restraining order targeted Kalshi, Polymarket, Robinhood, Coinbase, Gemini, Crypto.com and others.
The CFTC filed its own suit to halt that order, and Crypto.com sought to join the agency’s action. Selig called the state’s emergency lawsuit “naked lawfare and a cynical political stunt.” He argued Louisiana had long allowed event-contract trading and should continue doing so while the case proceeds. Those statements are Selig’s position, not a court finding.
The CFTC also sued Arkansas, bringing to a dozen the states where the agency has filed suits to defend its authority over prediction markets. Arkansas had sued Kalshi on November 4, accusing it of operating an illegal gambling business. The Louisiana and Arkansas disputes remained unresolved in the latest reported proceedings.
Another report covers a separate SEC and CFTC lawsuit over alleged crypto fraud.
Commission Nominations Add a Near-Term Step
Selig is the CFTC’s only commissioner, although the agency is legally meant to have five. The White House nominated Nathan Anonick, a Republican Senate Agriculture Committee staffer, and Matthew Rowland, a Democratic pick who served as a senior adviser to a Democratic commissioner. The committee was scheduled to hold their confirmation hearing on Tuesday.
The source said a larger commission could make policy deliberations broader and give minority-party members a chance to record dissents that may later support legal challenges. It also noted that commissioners are expected to abstain when they have conflicts. Because Selig is the sole commissioner, he cannot recuse himself from an action that requires a CFTC decision. The source said additional commissioners could make deliberations more deliberative and allow minority members to record dissents.
The senators ask the agency to pause its directive while the lawsuits continue. The nominees’ Senate hearing is the next stated step.

